1 Vuran

Life On Other Planets Essay Definition

Winston Churchill, British&#;prime minister and one of history&#;s most influential statesmen, was undoubtedly a man with weighty questions on his mind. How best to save the British Empire? he must have mused. What will the postwar world look like? he surely wondered. But the legendary leader also focused his prodigious mind on less pragmatic questions. For instance: Is there life on other planets?

In fact, in , Churchill penned a lengthy essay on this very topic, which was never published. Besides displaying a strong grasp of contemporary astrophysics and a scientific mind, he came to a breathtaking conclusion: We are probably not alone in the universe.&#;The long-lost piece of&#;Churchilliana has just floated up to the surface again, thanks to an article&#;written by&#;astrophysicist Mario Livio in this week's edition of the journal Nature analyzing Churchill's work.&#;

&#;With hundreds of thousands of nebulae, each containing thousands of millions of suns, the odds are enormous that there must be immense numbers which possess planets whose circumstances would not render life impossible,&#; Churchill concluded in his essay. He wrote these words on the eve of World War II&#;more than half a century before exoplanets were discovered. &#;

Until last year, Churchill's thoughts on the problem of alien life had been all but lost to history. The reason: His&#;page&#;typed&#;draft was never published. Sometime in the late s, Churchill revised the essay while visiting the seaside villa of publisher Emery Reves, but the text still didn't see the light of day. It appears to have languished in the Reves house until Emery's wife Wendy gave it to the U.S. National Churchill Museum during the s.

Last year, the museum&#;s new director, Timothy Riley, unearthed the essay in the museum's archives. When astrophysicist&#;Mario Livio&#;happened to visit the museum, Riley "thrust [the]&#;typewritten essay" into his hands, Livio writes in Nature. Riley was eager to hear the perspective of an astrophysicist. And Livio, for his part, was floored. &#;Imagine my thrill that I may be the first scientist to examine this essay,&#; he writes in Nature.

Churchill did his homework, Livio reports. Though he probably didn't pore over peer-reviewed scientific literature, the statesman seems to have read enough, and spoke with enough top scientists&#;including the physicist Frederick Lindemann, his friend and later his official&#;scientific adviser&#;to have had a strong grasp of the major theories and ideas of his time. But that wasn't what left the deepest impression on Livio.

&#;To me the most impressive part of the essay&#;other than the fact that he was interested in it at all, which is pretty remarkable&#;is really the way that he thinks,&#; Livio says. &#;He approached the problem just as a scientist today would. To answer his question 'Are we alone in the universe?' he started by defining life. Then he said, 'OK, what does life require? What are the necessary conditions for life to exist?'&#;

Churchill identified liquid water, for example, as a primary requirement. While he acknowledged the possibility that forms of life could exist dependent on some other liquid, he concluded that &#;nothing in our present knowledge entitles us to make such an assumption.&#;&#;&#;

"This is exactly what we still do today: Try to find life by following the water,&#; Livio says. &#;But next, Churchill asked 'What does it take for liquid water to be there?' And so he identified this thing that today we call the habitable zone.&#;

By breaking down the challenge into its component parts, Churchill ended up delving into the factors necessary to create what is now known as the &#;Goldilocks zone&#; around a star: that elusive region in which a life-sustaining planet could theoretically exist. In our own solar system, he concluded, only Mars and Venus could possibly harbor life outside of&#;Earth. The other planets don't have the right temperatures, Churchill noted, while the Moon and asteroids lack sufficient gravity to trap gasses and sustain atmospheres.

Turning his gaze beyond our own solar system raised even more possibilities for life, at least in Churchill's mind. &#;The sun is merely one star in our galaxy, which contains several thousand millions of others,&#; he wrote. Planetary formation would be rather rare around those stars, he admitted, drawing on a then-popular theory of noted physicist and astronomer James Jeans. But what if that theory turned out to be incorrect? (In fact, it has now been disproven.)

&#;That's what I find really fascinating,&#; Livio notes. &#;The healthy skepticism that he displayed is remarkable.&#;

Churchill suggested that different planetary formation theories may mean that many such planets may exist which &#;will be the right size to keep on their surface water and possibly an atmosphere of some sort.&#; Of that group, some may also be &#;at the proper distance from their parent sun to maintain a suitable temperature.&#;

The statesman even expected that some day, &#;possibly even in the not very distant future,&#; visitors might see for themselves whether there is life on the moon, or even Mars.

But what was Winston Churchill doing penning a lengthy essay on the probability of alien life in the first place? After all, it was the&#;eve of a war that would decide the fate of the free world, and Churchill was about to become Prime Minister of the United Kingdom.

Such an undertaking was actually quite typical for Churchill, notes Andrew Nahum, Keeper Emeritus at the Science Museum, London, because it reflects both his scientific curiosity and his recurring need to write for money. It was skill with the pen that often supported Churchill and his family's lavish lifestyle (recall that he won the Nobel Prize for Literature, with a monetary award of , Swedish Kroner worth about $, today).

&#;One recent biography is entitled No More Champagne: Churchill And His Money,&#; Nahum says. &#;That was a phrase he put into a note to his wife about austerity measures. But he didn't know much about austerity. He liked luxury so he wrote like crazy, both books and articles that his agent circulated widely.&#; &#;

That&#;s not to say that Churchill was simply slinging copy about aliens&#;for a paycheck. &#;He was profoundly interested in the sciences and he read very widely,&#; notes Nahum, who curated the Science Museum exhibition &#;Churchill's Scientists.&#;&#;Nahum relates the tale of how as Chancellor of the Exchequer, Churchill was once sent a book on quantum physics, and later admitted that it had occupied him for the better part of a day that should have been spent balancing the British budget.

He not only read scientific content voraciously, but wrote on the topic as well. In a issue of Nash's Pall Mall Magazine, Churchill anticipated the power of atomic weapons. &#;Might not a bomb no bigger than an orange be found to possess secret power to destroy a whole block of buildings nay, to blast a township at a stroke?&#; he warned. In , he anticipated the rise of test-tube meat in the magazine&#;Popular Mechanics: &#;Fifty years hence, we shall escape the absurdity of growing a whole chicken in order to eat the breast or the wing, by growing these parts separately in a suitable medium,&#; he wrote.

In he authored three essays, tackling not just extraterrestrial life but the evolution of life on Earth and the popular biology of the human body. Two were published during by the Sunday Dispatch, Nahum discovered when reading Churchill's papers at the University of Cambridge. It remains a mystery why his thoughts on alien life went unpublished.

In the rediscovered essay, Churchill admits that, because of the great distances between us and other planet-harboring stars,&#;we may never know if his hunch that life is scattered among the vastness of the cosmos is correct. Yet even without proof, Churchill seems to have convinced himself that such a possibility was likely&#;perhaps by swapping his scientific mind for one more finely attuned to the human condition during the troubled 20th&#;century.

&#;I, for one, am not so immensely impressed by the success we are making of our civilization here that I am prepared to think we are the only spot in this immense universe which contains living, thinking creatures,&#; he wrote, &#;or that we are the highest type of mental and physical development which has ever appeared in the vast compass of space and time.&#;

Seventy-five years after Churchill's bold speculations, there's still no proof that life exists on other worlds. But, as was often the case, his analysis of our own still seems prescient.

Like this article?
SIGN UP for our newsletter

About Brian Handwerk

We Recommend

Life On Other Planets Essay

One of the most common unanswered questions scientists find themselves asking is "Is there life on other planets?" Since the first famously documented UFO sighting in , the idea of extra-terrestrial life has been debated almost non-stop. The subject has inspired many TV programs, such as The X-Files, and films (Mars Attacks, Independence Day, and the Men in Black films to name but a few). Scientists have come up with many new ideas and ways of trying to either prove or disprove the existence of life elsewhere.

Mars is a very similar planet to earth in relation to size and atmosphere. Therefore it seemed like the most likely place to search for life. At the end of the 19th century, an American named Percival Lowell built himself an observatory so that it was possible for him to study Mars in intimate detail when its orbit was closest to Earth. At this time it had recently been suggested that the planet had a system of channels on the surface, present from the evaporation of flowing water. Looking through his telescope Lowell became convinced he could see a network of artificial canals. This led him to believe that there were intelligent beings on Mars who had built these canals. However, spacecraft have now visited Mars and found that there is no evidence of water at all. It is now thought that the lines he could see were the combination of Lowell's overactive imagination, and scratches on the lens of his telescope. We are now searching one of Jupiter's moons, Europa, as this seems to be the next likely place to hold life.
It is seen to be more likely, however, that we will find less intelligent life in one of two different ways:
It may be possible for us to obtain material from another planet or moon or star from elsewhere in the Solar System. Spacecraft may be able to visit these bodies and, for example, use a robot to collect material for examination. This may be examined on site, or brought to Earth to be investigated in laboratory conditions. They could be tested for things such as evidence of fossilised organisms. Another, possibly slightly far-fetched hope is that we may find simple organisms like bacteria actually living on the desired planet. These ideas spanned from the discovery of rock on our planet that originated from Mars; knocked from the planet when a comet collided with it. In a group of scientists created conflict by claiming that they had found evidence of fossilised bacteria in one of these rocks, but other scientists disputed this idea.
The other possibility is that we can examine the atmosphere of other likely planets or moons. The planet Earth is largely made up of oxygen (20%) due to the presence of photosynthesising plants producing oxygen as a waste product. If an indication of oxygen appeared in a different planetary atmosphere, it would have a high chance of holding life forms on it. To learn about different atmospheres it isn't mandatory to visit the planet. We can find this information by

Loading: Checking Spelling


Read more

Solar System Formation Essay

words - 8 pages Our sun is the central pivot point to which or entire planet and solar system is built around. With out it all life on our planet would cease to exist. Within this paper we will explore how our Sun and solar system formed and came to resemble what we see today. The Big Bang, the alpha of existence for the building blocks of stars, happened approximately fourteen billion years ago. The elements produced by the big bang consisted of hydrogen

The emergence of a new field in science - Exobiology

words - 2 pages Exobiology, also known as Astrobiology, refers to the study of the conditions necessary to support the independent development of extraterrestrial life. Direct proof has not yet been found of life anywhere in the universe other than on the Earth, but scientifically sound arguments have been proposed in support of such a possibility. The findings of modern astronomy

The Existence Of Extraterrestrial Life

words - 6 pages The idea of aliens has been a topic numerous Hollywood movie producers and writers have been creating blockbuster movies and novels since with the French movie A Trip to the Moon. The existence of Extraterrestrial life has been seen as a possibility through the discovery of Exoplanets, Kepler Missions, and mathematical formulas. Others doubt the possibilities of an Alien species such as Enrico Fermi, and Pope Zachary. Although the thought of

Jupiter: The Gas Planet

words - 6 pages Jove, Jowisz, the gas planet, the stormy planet, whatever you call it, these are all names for the biggest planet in our solar system, the fifth planet from the sun, Jupiter. The Romans named this planet after their god of the sky and thunder. This planet has times as much mass as the earth, and its diameter is 11 times the earth’s diameter. Since this planet is the fastest spinning (rotates in less than 10 hours), it is flattened at the

Pluto as a Dwarf Planet

words - 6 pages By definition from a Merriam- Webster Dictionary a planet is “any of the large bodies that revolve around the sun in the solar system which have a similar body to them”. This is not a very specific explanation and makes it hard to fully grasp what it means; at this you could easily say that in fact Pluto a planet. However if you look at a scientific encyclopedia the definition is much different and more specific. The Access Science Encyclopedia

Identify data sources and gather secondary information to describe the probable origins of the Universe.

words - 2 pages The most popular and accepted theory for the origin of the universe is the Big Bang Theory. This theory states that the universe began about 10 billion years ago in a violent explosion; every particle started rushing apart from every other particle in an early super-dense phase. This explosion sent energy and matter flying all over the place. However, there is an argument

Pluto: The Downgraded Planet

words - 6 pages Introduction Pluto will always be considered a planet to me despite what NASA and the IAU has to say about it. As a kid, I was always fascinated by Pluto; since it was the smallest of the 9 planets. The main reason was because it is the smallest of the planets in our solar system and was the last of the 9 planets to be discovered. In , when I learned that Pluto was downgraded to a dwarf planet by the International Astronomical Union (IAU),

About the SETI program and Extraterrestrial life.

words - 5 pages "SETI-the Search for Extraterrestrials"In the long adventure to find extraterrestrial intelligence, there has been many obstacles trying to get the signals the scientist need to prove ETI. SETI(The Search for extraterrestrial Intelligence) is a group of scientist searching the unknown for life. The main character in this search is Frank

Renaissance View of the Universe

words - 3 pages THE RENAISSANCE VIEW OF THE UNIVERSEThrough history people have been very interested in what lay above them. Every night as the people would go to sleep they would look up and wonder, what are those white dots up there? Some of the astrologers who would observe the night sky knowing that the white dots are planets and stars were convinced that the planets had an influence on their people, and so would spend the night trying to find

Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence is an Ongoing Process

words - 6 pages Search for extraterrestrial intelligence is an ongoing process. Understanding life is the first step. When looking for life in our solar system and universe, the first place to begin the search for life is to look at life on Earth. Earth has six properties found in all organisms and eight possible theories to how life begin. Over 3 billion years ago till the present; life has gone from a single organism to what it is now. Natural selection

Is There Anyone Out There?

words - 6 pages Earth is small. Many people find it hard to believe, but when one thinks of earth in its context, amongst billions of galaxies, stars, planets, and an infinite universe, earth is a mere grain of sand on the beach that is space. With this in mind, one may, quite understandably, find it hard to believe that earth is the only planet that sustains life. With today’s advanced technology and science, extensive evidence has been found suggesting a great

Leave a Comment


Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *