1 Kazijora

Conflict Resolution Case Study Analysis In Education

A Case Study on Conflict Management

A Case Study on Conflict Management
Shirley and Abdul both work for a software development company. The manager of the new product division was originally the leader of the project team for which she interviewed and hired Abdul. Shirley, another project team member, also interviewed Abdul, but strongly opposed hiring him for the project because she thought he was not competent to do the job.
Seven months after Abdul was hired, the manager left the project to start her own company and recommended that Abdul and Shirley serve as joint project leaders. Shirley agreed reluctantly?with the stipulation that it be made clear she was not working for Abdul. The General Manager consented; Shirley and Abdul were to share the project leadership.
Within a month Shirley was angry because Abdul was representing himself to others as the leader of the entire project and giving the impression that Shirley was working for him. Now Shirley and Abdul are meeting with you to see if you can resolve the conflict between them.
Shirley says: "Right after the joint leadership arrangement was reached with the General Manager, Abdul called a meeting of the project team without even consulting me about the time or content. He just told me when it was being held and said I should be there. At the meeting, Abdul reviewed everyone's duties line by line, including mine, treating me as just another team member working for him. He sends out letters and signs himself as project director, which obviously implies to others that I am working for him."
Abdul says: "Shirley is all hung up with feelings of power and titles. Just because I sign myself as project director doesn't mean she is working for me. I don't see anything to get excited about. What difference does it make? She is too sensitive about everything. I call a meeting and right away she thinks I'm trying to run everything. Shirley has other things to do?other projects to run?so she doesn't pay too much attention to this one. She mostly lets things slide. But when I take the initiative to set up a meeting, she starts jumping up and down about how I am trying to make her work for me."
Question Regarding This Conflict
1. Abdul and Shirley seem to have several conflicts occurring simultaneously. Identify as many of these individual conflicts as possible.
2. What are the possible ways to deal with the conflict between Abdul and Shirley (not just the ones that you would recommend, but all of the options)?
3. Given all the benefits of retrospection, what could or should have been done to avoid this conflict in the first place?

Solution Summary

In this case scenario there are several issues between Shirley and Abdul. First and foremost, Shirley feels that Abdul is incompetent, thus her perceptions of his capabilities are skewed and there is a lack of respect to begin with. Shirley also seems to have an issue with titles and placement of authority (as Abdul mentions in his summation of the conflict).

Related BrainMass Content

Ace Consulting Case Study: Building Effective Teams

to the Ace Consulting Case Study and building However, recent studies of global
leadership and the Library Committees Conflict Management Dialoguing Employee

Sources of Conflict Within an Organization

In some cases, a disputant or third party prefers In their study, they used the term
"problem Ewing's () case studies of due process procedures indicated

AeroTech Case Study

I'm not sure that the training and management coaching programs the team objectives
within the set constraints (Case study, nd resolve conflicts within the team

Kinder Morgan Buyout Raises Ethical Questions

The conflict of interest is that how can an Case Study Discussion Questions 2. What
types of mechanisms could is direct dialogue between the conflicting parties

FMC Aberdeen case study

is important to have a contingency plan in case of either behavior is an important
field of study of an of environment, the management has no conflict with the

Negotiation Case Study

The expert examines negotiation case study. The issues and parties to the
conflict/negotiation are identified but he also worries that his studies are suffering

The Co-Determination Case Study

A Case Study. During his studies he spent one semester at the University of
Trier/Germany. in German (BA in German), and also his children had studied German

Threats to validity in a research study

Conflict Management. This area has been studied, but it is always changing. Planning
strategically for a diverse talent pool: A case study. Readings, Cases,.

Negotiation Strategy Article Analysis

methods such as surveys, interviews and case studies since it in this study is
aggregated over cases, but an Walgreens: A case study in health care issues and

Finance Case Study: River Beverages' Budgeting Process

Finance Case Study: River Beverages' Budgeting Process. the restaurant sold over
one million cases of our If that be the case then involving the divisional

Case Studies Focus on Teachers' Everyday Problems

Is "I'm bored!" one of your students' favorite expressions? Are name-calling and play-fighting problems that you face every day in your classroom? Follow six classroom teachers as they struggle to understand and find workable solutions to these and other everyday problems in a new book from author Ruth Charney.

"Sometimes I fear that we will lose faith, faith in ourselves and our children. Many teachers find their classes harder, their children demonstrating fewer academic and social skills. In my school, too, the challenges can be daunting. More than ever we need to feel the courage and hope of our professions. We need the time and stamina to problem-solve, to search in our own midst for effective strategies and to collaborate"

And that's the thrust behind a new bookHabits of Goodness: Case Studies in the Social Curriculumfrom Ruth Charney, author of Teaching Children to Care. Charney has invited six educators to each share a problem experienced in the classroom and to focus on that problem, "to search in their own midst for effective strategies and to collaborate"

The six case studies in this volume focus on "big" problems, problems that have no easy solutions. They're problems that every teacher faces on a daily basis. To give you an idea of the kinds of problems the six teachers addressed, following are excerpts from four of the Habits of Goodness case studies:

Teacher Eileen Marinari focuses on getting her kindergartners to talk "real talk":

"It seems that over the years my students have become increasingly non-verbal and passiveThey need to be prodded to express themselves in a class discussion or to share something about themselves. When they do speak, they offer only the required amount of information"

Teacher Linda Matthews chose to focus on conflict resolution with her first graders:

"Early in September I introduce them to a conflict resolution process called SETS, an acronym for
  • Stop and get cool.
  • Explain what you are unhappy about.
  • Talk at the table.
  • Shake hands.

Together we practice those techniques so the children can learn to use them on their ownSo I puzzled why, in spite of all these arrangements, some children still persisted in their need to check in with me before trying to resolve their problems"

Teacher Cathy Jaques' case study focuses on her desire to teach respect to the fourth graders in her class, to put an end to the play-fighting and the name-calling she regularly observes:

"Classes had been dismissed for lunch and the hallway was alive with kids going into lockers, heading for rest rooms, and meeting friendsI saw Patricia and James playfully arguing. Suddenly, with the grace of a dancer, Patricia's leg shot out and kicked a laughing James with a sideswipe worthy of Jean-Claude Van Damme"

Teacher Colette Kaplan searched for ways to get her fifth-grade students (whose favorite line seemed to be "I'm bored!") to take some responsibility for "unboring" themselves. Her problem came to light one October day:

"I was particularly looking forward to our social studies period, eager to watch my fifth graders dig into their projects on Native Americans. Anna and Claudia had chosen to work together studying Native American dwellings. This morning found them sitting at a cluster of desks chatting quietly. Their desktops were empty.
Their talk had nothing to do with longhouses or teepees[Ms. Kaplan intervenes] 'Are you girls having difficulty getting started today?' They exchanged nervous glances; they had been 'caught!''We're bored,' Claudia announced."

Getting kids to open up; developing the skills needed to create independent problem-solvers; developing respect among students; and getting kids to take responsibility for their own learning. Those are the sorts of problems teachers face every day. Big problems. Problems without simple answers.

In Habits of Goodness, each of the six teachers works to solve a problem that has been bothering her. Each comes up with solutions that work for her. But the best part of Habits of Goodness is that the teachers model an approach that can be applied by any educator to any problem. We follow along over the course of a school year as each teacher takes time to reflect on the problem, observe her students' actions, question her solutions personally and with a selected peer, and determine a course of action. The solutions are thoughtful and creative (as with Cathy Jacques, who gets her students to follow the case-study approach as they write essays about name-calling, essays that result in heart-rending classroom discussions).

We, the readers, follow as each teacher focuses on a problem and seeks solutions that will workfor her, for now. The teachers vow to continue to reflect on those problems, because the problems aren't simple ones. But, in the end, the teachers have grown. Each looks forward to the next school year, a year when she can begin in September to apply all she has learned from the efforts of the past year.

Habits of Goodness: Case Studies in the Social Curriculum by Ruth Sidney Charney is published by the Northeast Foundation for Children. The book is available from NEFC by calling the Foundation at (Single copy price: $) The Northeast Foundation for Children is a private, non-profit educational foundation that works to improve the quality of classroom teaching through its professional development programs, summer workshops, long-term collaborations, and teacher resources. NEFC publishes The Responsive Classroom, a newsletter for teachers, three times a year (January, April, and August). Subscriptions are free to educators. To initiate a subscription, mail (to ensure that they have accurate mailing information) your name; your address; your city, state, and ZIP; your title or grade level taught; and your school name to: Northeast Foundation for Children, 71 Montague City Rd., Greenfield, MA .

You can read a reprint of a Responsive Classroom article which appeared several weeks ago on Education World at /a_lesson/lesson/lessonshtml. "Pretzels" describes a weekly activity that allows the exchange of compliments and criticism among the students in your class; the Pretzels exercise can help to resolve conflicts and teach children how to properly handle conflict.

Article by Gary Hopkins
Education World® Editor-in-Chief
Copyright © Education World


Leave a Comment


Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *